|
|
Main
Researcher: Sylvie Robichaud-Ekstrand RN., Ph.D. Montreal, Heart Institute
and Montreal University, Canada.Co-researchers:
Emmanuel Comte et al.
Goal :
The
main purpose of this study was to examine the influence of music on
CHD patientsí relaxation levels, while waiting for cardiac catherization
in a ambulatory care unit, or being observed at the emergency
department (ER).
Research
Design and Procedure:
In a pre-test post-test experimental
design, subjets were randomly assigned to listen to relaxing music of
their choice, or be part of the control group. Data (before and after
listening to music) were collected in the morning
on the ambulatory care unit (before patients were transferred to
the catherization laboratory), or in the evening for those at ER waiting
to be hospitalized or send be home.
Subjects:
Convenience sample included
196 patients between age 21 and 85 years (6+11 years), where 137
(70%) come from the ambulatory care unit, and 57 (30%) from the ER. Most
patients were men (68%), many experienced their first major angina episode(46%)
and were hospitalized for their first time (58%). Identified music producing
positive impact included :
classical (69%), popular (80%), country-western (64%) and jazz
(48%). At pre-test, no difference were found between subjects listening
to music and the control group (p >
0.05). However
certain patientís characteristics were different between the ambulatory
care department and the ER, as well as between participants and non-participants
(p <
0.05).
Instrument:
Eight numeric Likert
Scales (0 to 10) (Visual Analogue Scales) were utilized to evaluate patientís
perceived relaxation level. This instrument has 0.71 Crombach alpha coefficient.
Anxiety levels were positively correlated with levels of frustration (r=0.41),
worries (r = 0.61) and negatively with relaxation (r = -0.38).
Frustation levels correlated positively with irritation due to noise (r
= 0,31) and worries (r
= 0.44). Relaxation levels were associated with comfort (r = 0,54),
control (r = 0.30) and negatively
with anxiety (r = -0.38) and worries (r = -0,38) (p
< 0.05).
Results:
Listening to relaxing music had beneficial effect on CHD patientís perceived
relaxation level (p = 0.0004), indicated by : decreased anxiety
(p = 0.01), and increased control (p = 0.003) and relaxation
(p = 0.001). No differences existed on perceived levels of frustration,
comfort, irritation to noise, worries, retrosternal pain, number of angina
and anxiety- relieving medication
consumed, heart rate, blood pressures, premature ventricular
and supra ventricular arrhythmias, and ST segment depression(p
> 0.05).
At the ER, all relaxation measures remained similar (p >
0.05), with the exception
of frustration levels (p = 0.005). In both departments, more women
(p = 0.0002) and persons who were not in the habit to listen to
music (p = 0.001), decided not to participate in this study. The
proportion of women not willing to participate was higher in the ER (55%)
than in the ambulatory care unit (38%) (p = 0.0002). At the ER,
the non participants were older (p = 0.006). At the ambulatory
care unit, non-participants had been previously hospitalized (p
= 0.04).
Conclusion:
Listening to relaxing music is an inexpensive nursing intervention which
increases CHD patientís perceived relaxation level while waiting for cardiac
catherization. These results were not observed in the ER. Non participantís
characteristics differed from participantís.
Sylvie
Robichaud-Ekstrand, R.N., PhD. Montreal
University, Montreal Heart Institute.
Ambulatory
care unit, emergency department (ER) of Heart Institute of Montreal (Qc)
Canada affiliated to Montreal University.
Main
researcher: Sylvie Robichaud-Ekstrand, RN, PhD.
Sylvie.Robichaud-Ekstrand@umontreal.ca
Collaborators:
| Céline
Castonguay, B.Sc.Inf |
Research trainee |
| Emmanuel
Comte |
Soundlogist,
musician, researcher |
| Huguette
Choisnet, inf |
Unit
head specialized Care, ambulatory care unit |
| Pierre
DeGuise, M.D |
Emergency
Medical coordinator |
| Yannick
Giroux,, B.Sc.Inf |
Research
Assistant |
| François
Harel, M.Sc.Stat |
Statistics
Consultant |
| Micheline
Langlois, M.Sc.Inf |
Nurse
Care Manager |
| Danielle
Perrault, B.Sc. Inf |
Unit
head of Emergency Specialized Care |
| Maryse
Proulx, B.Sc. Inf. |
Research
trainee |
| Carole
Sanscartier, A.M.A. |
Medical Archivist |
| Mario
Talajic, M.D |
Electro
physiology Departmental Head, Medical Director |
| Marika
Vermeesch, B.Sc.Inf |
Research
Assistant |
| Christine
Villemaire, M.Sc. |
Research
Assistant electro
physiology unit |
Sponsors:
Sony Canada, Sony Music.

|